The Real Dilema

Nov. 25th, 2008 · 10:47 pm · Category: General

…is not about making or buying the pie crust, but what do you put in it? As usual, I’m responsible for two pies for Thanksgiving this year; one has to be pecan (unless I want to be disinherited). Pumpkin, sadly, is not an option, since there will be anti-pumpkin family members present. The second choice is traditionally Dutch apple. Maybe peach this year? I do have 50lbs of peaches that aren’t eating themselves…

Since this seems to be a favourite topic: what’s your favourite kind?

Tags: ,

9 Comments

  • Delle Says:

    My mum is particularly fond of making apple-based desserts, then making fun of my husband, son and I for being cannibals. We don’t really eat pies though.

    Delle’s last blog post: Maths

  • Annika Says:

    NO PUMPKIN?!>!?!

    Annika’s last blog post: Tens

  • Kirk Says:

    What sort of Communists don’t like pumpkin pie??!!

    My personal favorite is rhubarb.

  • Jess Says:

    If there’s no pumpkin, I don’t have another answer for you.

    Jess’s last blog post: Spectators of suicide

  • Amy Says:

    Pumpkin, sadly, is not an option, since there will be anti-pumpkin family members present.

    Um. … Um. … Uh … … … pumpkin.

    I tried my best to answer something else.

  • Vicki Says:

    I know, I know. But I am inclined to put up with small flaws like that considering that they put up with my giant neuroses (honestly, they’re far nicer to me then I deserve). That being said: the pecan pie could be considered the anti-pumpkin choice, right? So I might just go ahead and make pumpkin pie, even especially if Mike and I are the only ones who eat it.

  • allison Says:

    My preference is cherry pie, but it isn’t Thanksgiving without pumpkin! And that is all there is to that.

    allison’s last blog post: Help me, Obi-wan

  • starshine Says:

    I confess…I don’t like pumpkin pie either. I like pumpkin bread, pumpkin muffins (pretty much bread only baked into a muffin), pumpkin donuts, pumpkin whoopie pies filled with cream cheese frosting, even pumpkin fudge…but not pie. Oh, or ice cream either.

    Honestly, aside from pork pie, I’m not a big fan of pie. With the exception of chocolate pudding pie, topped with Cool Whip with a graham cracker crust.

  • Kim Says:

    Rhubarb pie is probably my favourite, but apple is the classic fall pie. Can’t really go wrong there.

    My French Canadian mother-in-law makes a divine sugar pie with maple syrup. Nom! I don’t actually LOVE pumpkin pie, either… Oh – and if I’m buying a pie from the farm market up the road, I invariably pick raspberry.

    It does seem wise to use some of your peaches, though…

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv Enabled